AlgoPuzzle Open the Builder
← Back to all articles

Platforms

MT4 vs MT5 vs cTrader: Which Should You Automate On?

By AlgoPuzzle · Published · Updated

For automated trading, MetaTrader 5 is the more capable of the two MetaTrader versions, MetaTrader 4 is the most widely offered, and cTrader takes a more modern, C#-based approach - but for most traders the broker decides, because each broker supports only some of them. The practical differences: MT4 EAs are written in MQL4, MT5 EAs in MQL5 and cTrader cBots in C#, and none runs on another platform. MT4 accounts are hedging-only; MT5 and cTrader accounts can be hedging or netting, which changes how several same-symbol trades behave. MT5's Strategy Tester is multi-threaded and can test on real tick data and several symbols at once, while MT4's tests one symbol on one thread. If your broker offers all three, pick the one whose tester and account type fit your strategy.

The three platforms side by side

MetaTrader 4MetaTrader 5cTrader
Automation languageMQL4MQL5C# (.NET)
Program nameExpert Advisor (.mq4 / .ex4)Expert Advisor (.mq5 / .ex5)cBot (.cs / .algo)
Account typesHedging onlyHedging or nettingHedged or netted
Chart timeframes921Many, plus tick, Renko and range charts
Pending order types4 (buy/sell limit, buy/sell stop)6 (adds buy stop limit, sell stop limit)Limit, stop and stop limit
Strategy testerSingle-threaded, one symbolMulti-threaded, multi-symbol, real ticksBacktesting and optimisation on tick or bar data
Code modelChecks conditions on each tick (OnTick)Checks conditions on each tick (OnTick)Event-driven (OnBar, OnTick, position events)

MetaTrader 4

The oldest and most widely supported - if a broker offers only one platform, it is often MT4. Every position gets its own ticket (no netting mode), which keeps multi-position logic simple. MetaQuotes has been moving brokers to MT5 for years and stopped issuing new MT4 licences, but existing MT4 servers still run and many brokers still offer it.

MetaTrader 5

More timeframes, more order types, market depth, and the stronger tester: multi-threaded optimisation, multi-symbol tests and "Every tick based on real ticks" modelling. The catch is the account type. On a netting account, several same-symbol orders merge into one position at the platform level, whatever your EA intends - worth knowing before you build a strategy that opens the same symbol from more than one rule.

cTrader

Popular with ECN-style brokers. cBots are written in C# and react to events - a new bar, a closed position - rather than running everything in one tick loop. It can express the same strategies as MT4/MT5, structured differently, and it offers both hedged and netted accounts.

How to decide, in order

  1. What your broker supports. This settles it for most people.
  2. Netting vs. hedging. If several rules may hold the same symbol at once, use a hedging account (MT4, MT5 hedging or cTrader hedged).
  3. Testing needs. If you want tests on real tick data or optimisation across many settings, MT5's tester is the strongest of the three.
  4. Familiarity. If you already know one platform's interface for monitoring live trades, that is worth something.

You don't have to commit before testing an idea: a strategy built once in AlgoPuzzle exports to MT5, MT4 and cTrader from the same blocks, so you can run it on whichever platform your broker offers. Already have an MT4 EA? Converting an MT4 EA to MT5 or cTrader shows how to move it without rewriting the code. On a Match-Trader account, which does not run EAs, see how to run a trading bot on Match-Trader. If the broker rejects your stops on one of them, see the invalid stops error.

Common questions

Is MT5 better than MT4 for automated trading?

For most automated strategies, yes: MT5 has a multi-threaded, multi-symbol Strategy Tester with real-tick modelling, more timeframes and order types, and both hedging and netting accounts. MT4 remains more widely offered by brokers.

Can MT4 EAs run on MT5?

No. MT4 EAs are written in MQL4 and compiled to .ex4, MT5 EAs in MQL5 and compiled to .ex5. An MT4 EA has to be rewritten or exported again for MT5.

Is MT4 discontinued?

MetaQuotes stopped issuing new MT4 licences and encourages brokers to move to MT5, but MT4 has not been switched off: existing MT4 servers still run and many brokers still offer it.

What language does cTrader use for bots?

cTrader cBots are written in C#, using the cTrader Automate API, and react to events such as a new bar or a closed position.

What is the difference between hedging and netting?

On a hedging account every trade is a separate position, even on the same symbol. On a netting account, trades on the same symbol are combined into one net position. MT4 is hedging only; MT5 and cTrader offer both.

Build once, export to all three - Free